We’re a gaggle of six graduate researchers with various skilled backgrounds and opinions on fossil gas firms’ position in funding associates program analysis. Three of us have been actively protesting fossil gas funding on the Doerr College. Three of us are in favor of sustaining an open dialogue with fossil gas firms. We agree that addressing local weather change is severe sufficient to demand a transparent strategic response from the College. Working collectively, we have now reached a consensus on really helpful standards for evaluating the sources and goals of analysis funding by way of affiliate applications, in addition to a set of actions for implementing these standards.
All of us endorse the next suggestions and we hope that they’ll contribute to a university-wide determination to undertake enforceable requirements for analysis funding supplied by fossil gas firms by way of affiliate teams.
In December of 2022, Stanford’s Workplace of the President established the Committee on Funding of Vitality Analysis and Training (CFERE), charged with “exploring and reporting on the problems raised by Stanford’s accepting funding from fossil gas firms.” The committee has to this point not made any findings publicly out there. We’re involved that the committee’s suggestions might come too late or fail to embody the management that Stanford should play within the vitality transition.
Our alignment on these suggestions demonstrates that stakeholders with totally different backgrounds and pursuits can discover widespread floor rooted in our values of integrity and transparency. This work represents a mannequin that we imagine might obtain widespread assist for affordable, actionable and verifiable standards for supporting analysis at Stanford. We now have shared the under suggestions with the CFERE and hope they’ll incorporate them into their very own findings. There isn’t a trigger for additional delay.
Suggestions ready and accredited by:
|Abstract of suggestions for industrial affiliate applications
To take impact instantly: Evaluation, establish and eradicate advantages to business donors that current a direct battle of curiosity. Particularly, by implementing Stanford’s current insurance policies for industrial affiliate applications.
Dissociate: Get rid of monetary sponsorship from any firm, commerce group or different group that engages in any of the next (see under for particulars on every criterion): Doesn’t present a reputable transition plan, doesn’t present clear information, has plans to conduct their operations in a way that’s at odds with a Paris-aligned transition pathway.
Set up a third-party enforcement board tasked with:
Imposing current insurance policies for industrial affiliate applications, together with establishing penalties for any violations according to Stanford’s Code of Conduct, overseeing dissociation and future re-association processes with business companions on a case-by-case foundation. Develop a concrete timeline for the above
Disclose: Strengthen current disclosure necessities throughout the College, together with by writing particular steering for conflicts of curiosity involving the fossil gas business.
Set up a transition pathways analysis initiative: Assist the creation of an initiative tasked with evaluating companions’ transition pathways and creating requirements for emissions accounting.
Particulars for Suggestion #2:
Dissociate: Get rid of monetary sponsorship from any firm, commerce group, or different group that engages in any of the next:
- Doesn’t present a reputable transition plan. A reputable transition contains, however is just not restricted to, all the following:
- A plan for diversification of property, comparable to growing proportion funding (i.e. capital expenditures) for clear vitality provide and finish use effectivity
- Web-zero emissions pathway that achieves a big discount in absolute degree of emissions and doesn’t depend on carbon offsets
- Adjustments in administration incentive constructions, for instance by way of Key Efficiency Incentives
- Doesn’t present clear information essential to guage the above, together with:
- Its emissions and carbon depth of its upstream operations (Scope 1 and a couple of emissions)
- Lobbying expenditures and funding of residents teams/entrance teams
- Within the final 5 years, has obstructed local weather coverage, as evidenced by actions together with, however not restricted to, the next:
- Documented selections to publicly downplay or contradict peer-reviewed local weather science
- Documented lobbying towards pro-climate laws, together with however not restricted to, lobbying
- For a decrease social value of carbon
- For much less stringent greenhouse gasoline emissions rules
- Documented opposition to renewable vitality tasks, immediately or by way of “astroturf” entrance teams (e.g. the California Drivers’ Alliance)
- A file of false or deceptive promoting, as adjudicated in court docket selections and/or peer-reviewed literature (for a database of court docket selections, see Columbia Regulation College’s International Local weather Change Litigation database)
Particulars for Suggestion #3:
Set up a third-party enforcement board: We outline “third get together” as a panel of Stanford associates, together with college students, who aren’t immediately accountable for financing of business affiliate applications. To deal with conflicts of curiosity, any board members should disclose funding from fossil gas firms. This board shall evaluate current business companions primarily based on the above standards and oversee the dissociation and re-association course of. This may contain:
- Speaking to any violating business companions and related principal investigators the actions they have to take with a purpose to abide by the above standards and supply a 60-day interval for them to reply. The 60-day timeline originates from Princeton Fossil Gas Dissociation. This serves for example to exhibit a concrete timeline.
- Appropriately sanctioning affiliate applications who proceed to obtain funding from violating business companions after the 60-day interval
- Set up a course of by which an business associate might re-associate (i.e. re-enter as a funder in an associates program) with the College if it has demonstrated compliance with the above standards
- Oversee implementation of a section out fund to assist the transition of any analysis applications whose operations could be impacted by dissociation
June Choi is a Ph.D. candidate in earth system science. Her analysis focuses on quantifying the impacts of local weather change to tell adaptation methods. Her earlier work concerned monitoring world local weather finance flows, setting requirements for inexperienced bonds and sustainable finance integrity.
Cedric Fraces is a Ph.D. pupil within the vitality sciences engineering division. His analysis focuses on a brand new class of numerical strategies for the simulation and uncertainty characterization of CO2 sequestration in geological formations. Previous to this work, Cedric spent a decade working as a reservoir engineer on main oilfields within the Center East and Latin America, in addition to CO2 sequestration tasks within the U.S. and Canada.
Rebecca Grekin is a Ph.D. candidate in vitality sciences engineering methods to scale back carbon emissions from the business constructing sector from heating and cooling programs by altering the operations of those programs. Previous to this work, she accomplished a grasp’s in the identical division learning Scope 3 emissions, doing a deep dive into creating automated programs to estimate emissions from meals buying.
Yannai Kashtan is a Ph.D. candidate in earth system science, an organizer for the Coalition for a True College of Sustainability and a Knight-Hennessy Scholar. His doctoral analysis focuses on the health-related hazards of residential fossil-fueled home equipment.
Dr. Wennan Lengthy is a current graduate from the vitality science and engineering division at Stanford, the place he was suggested by professor Adam R. Brandt. He has experience in vitality engineering and life-cycle evaluation. His analysis curiosity is constructing simulators to calculate upstream greenhouse gasoline emissions throughout the oil and gasoline provide chain. Dr. Lengthy led the staff on the Archie Initiative to calculate the worldwide oil upstream carbon depth.
Daly Wettermark is a grasp’s pupil in environmental engineering learning operational efficiencies for wastewater remedy and reuse. She can be a local weather activist, and he or she has beforehand labored as an engineer in product improvement and company sustainability within the water business.